+ Add Critic Score

Submit a Critic Score

Score:

Name of Critic:

Close

Saintsbury Pinot Noir Garnet Carneros 2014

Member Review by la dut:

A beautiful garnet red color (kind of just like the name, HA!). The nose is very oaky, reminiscent of sawdust with slight tobacco notes, smoke, and hints of grilled red meat. Dusty with plum, raspberry, and sweet cherry. Initially smooth and medium-full bodied, the wine transitions toward more aggressive tannins, with a feel like suede on the tongue. Sweet cherries and raspberry present initially, and licorice and Asian herbs and spices introduce themselves on the mid-palate. The finish is grippy with lingering cigar, oak, and red fruits. This wine was typically American in style: Very oak driven and powerful. Complex enough, but slightly out of balance, and very young.

Add winemaker's notes
  • + My Wines

    My Wines

    Save in My Wines

    Add to Wishlist

    My Cellar

  • List It
  • Add Review
3.2698360655738 5 0.5
Average Rating Rate It Add
Saintsbury:
First published in 1920, George Saintsbury’s “Notes on a Cellar-Book” has inspired many to experiment widely and to form opinions unaffected by the fashion of the day. Included in those ranks are Mr. Ward and Mr. Graves, who named their winery in honor of Professor Saintsbury.

Member Reviews for Saintsbury Pinot Noir Garnet Carneros

Add your review
Snooth User: la dut
670405189
3.00 5
Vintage: 2009 07/24/2011

A beautiful garnet red color (kind of just like the name, HA!). The nose is very oaky, reminiscent of sawdust with slight tobacco notes, smoke, and hints of grilled red meat. Dusty with plum, raspberry, and sweet cherry. Initially smooth and medium-full bodied, the wine transitions toward more aggressive tannins, with a feel like suede on the tongue. Sweet cherries and raspberry present initially, and licorice and Asian herbs and spices introduce themselves on the mid-palate. The finish is grippy with lingering cigar, oak, and red fruits. This wine was typically American in style: Very oak driven and powerful. Complex enough, but slightly out of balance, and very young.


Snooth User: Takatsuna
77835126
3.00 5
Vintage: 2009 07/05/2011

Three glasses


Snooth User: twalsh
13217310
4.00 5
Vintage: 2006 02/05/2009

Light--> medium-bodied pinot noir. Crisp with just the right amount of fruit and thoroughly enjoyable on its own.


Snooth User: TOTJr
81883735
4.00 5
Vintage: 2005 04/27/2011

Family...Copeland family starter!!! 3-27


Snooth User: wumanjoo
324257
4.00 5
Vintage: 2005 11/06/2007

The Saintsbury Garnet Pinot is not as complex as the more expensive Carneros Pinot Noirs, but it's excellent in its price range. At $15, this is my favorite budget-friendly pinot.


Snooth User: Salmanazar138
6899152
4.00 5
Vintage: 2005 05/04/2008

Four glasses


Snooth User: mjdvorkin
31993245
2.50 5
Vintage: 2004 09/27/2007

Two and a half glasses


1 2

External Reviews for Saintsbury Pinot Noir Garnet Carneros

External Review
Vintage: 2009 06/22/2011

Fresh, vibrant and snappy, offering crisp dark berry fruit, with spice, mineral and cedar flavors. Full-bodied and persistent. Drink now through 2015.


External Review
Vintage: 2009 06/22/2011

The two Pinot Noirs include the screw cap-finished 2009 Garnet. This is a delightful, fruit-driven, lighter style of Pinot with plenty of cherries and spice as well as a hint of herbs. Simple, medium-bodied, but very satisfying, it should be drunk over the next several years.


External Review
Vintage: 2009 01/04/2012

Garnet long has been one of Californiarsquo;s greatest entry-level Pinot Noirs, and it still is. Maybe the best. The rsquo;09 reflects the balanced vintage. Itrsquo;s a dry, silky, light-bodied wine, with pretty raspberry and cola flavors.


External Review
Vintage: 2009 02/07/2013

Aromas of black cherry, black tea, forest floor; loamy, full mouthfeel.


External Review
Vintage: 2009 05/18/2011

A smooth, elegant, refined style, with ripe cherry, mushroom, earth and anise flavors that pick up a floral note. Drink now through 2004.


External Review
Vintage: 2009 05/18/2011

Medium cherry-red. Vibrant aromas of crushed cherry and raspberry. Fruity, supple and juicy, with a restrained sweetness to the red fruit and spice flavors. Rich for this bottling, and very easy to drink. Finishes fresh, with a dusting of tannins and good length.


External Review
Vintage: 2009 05/18/2011

Lots of ripe, rich, jammy blackberry and black cherry fruit that is supple and well-centered, offering depth and concentration, with surprisingly firm tannins (for Garnet). A winner. Drink now through 2005.


1 2 3 4


Photos

1 2 3 4 5  ...  11

+ Add Image

Best Wine Deals

  • $24.99
    17% off
    Chateau Ste. Michelle Canoe Ridge Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot Syrah United States Washington Columbia Valley Chateau Ste. Michelle United States
    Chateau Ste. Michelle Canoe Ridge Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot Syrah United States Washington Columbia Valley Chateau Ste. Michelle United States 2008
  • $15.99
    16% off
    Lioco Sonoma County Chardonnay
    Lioco Sonoma County Chardonnay 2011
See More Deals

Pinot Noir Top Lists







Snooth Media Network