Prisoner Orin Swift Napa 2009

  • WS: 93

    Wine Spectator Score

    93

    Close
  • RP: 92

    Robert Parker Score

    92

    Close
  • WE: 91

    Wine Enthusiast Score

    91

    Close
  • + Wine critic

    Submit a Critic Score

    Score:

    Name of Critic:

    Close
Sunfish Cellars
Lilydale, MN (900 mi)
USD 89.99
750ml
Buy Now
Wines Anywhere
Brick, NJ (190 mi)
USD 26.99
750ml
Buy Now
See 100 more prices »

Sweet and dusty on the nose, this shows aromas of tight red fruits flecked with mineral and allspice notes. On entry the texture is quite silky wit... Read more

As usual Coudoulet punches well above it's price class! This is so well framed with the assertive structure of 2005 wrapped in a deep flannelly bla... Read more

Nose is very aromatic, leather, meat, black fruit, slightly candied with lovely smoke and herb nuances but in time this turns into an awesome poop-... Read more

Set your rating:
Save

Examples: Value Wine, Would Recommend, For the Cellar, Etc...
Suggested Recipe Pairing presented by
Coconut Rice Sweet Potato Cheesecake

RiceSelect's creamy Arborio gets blended with sweet potato, coconut milk and vanilla to create this decadent cheesecake. Pairs well with Saunternes; a white dessert wine that has hints of coconut from aging in oak barrels.

View Recipe


All Prices

Shipping to:

Editorial Reviews for Prisoner Orin Swift Napa

Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
0.00 5
Vintage: 2010 02/12/2013

Sweet and dusty on the nose, this shows aromas of tight red fruits flecked with mineral and allspice notes. On entry the texture is quite silky with black cherry fruit that is threaded with a contrasting medicinal edge. There is lovely purity and aromatic fruit, violet and sweet spice notes that are wrapped up in a restrained, slightly chewy package. The finish is long and pure, exhibiting excellent tension and focus in the mouth and right through the end. A bit reticent today but really very fine. 94pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
4.50 5
Vintage: 2005 04/07/2009

As usual Coudoulet punches well above it's price class! This is so well framed with the assertive structure of 2005 wrapped in a deep flannelly blanket of spicy plum fruits. There are nice mineral, floral and earthen notes here but this is really about wonderfully pure, deep fruit. I love Coudoulet with some age on, I just, regrettably, finished my stash of 1998s which were absolutely singing. In a world where $50 Cheateauneuf have become the norm this remain a serious bargain. 91pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
4.50 5
Vintage: 2005 02/06/2013

Nose is very aromatic, leather, meat, black fruit, slightly candied with lovely smoke and herb nuances but in time this turns into an awesome poop-s-thon. Turn back the clock to beaucastel of days gone by all backed up with super clean fresh black fruit Big and slightly thick in the mouth, there is an early minty edge here followed by a palate full of tight but rich, muscular, meaty dark fruit filled with carob, earth and almost fudgy candied flavors. Finishing dry and dark with deep earthy notes hints of heat, pepperiness and some old woodiness this is still a bit tannic and firm in the mouth but at the same time it shows great precision and balance. A fabulous beaucastel. 94pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
2.50 5
Vintage: 2003 02/06/2013

Jammy black currant and blueberry fruit greet the nose showing off a bit of a pruny edge with very black peppery top notes and a slightly dusty character. In the mouth this has surprisingly intact acid, offering decent brightness and height in the mouth with lovely blackberry fruit but here is a fair amount of alcohol showing here, and while the fruit does show nice purity the wine is not particularly well balanced. 84pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
4.00 5
Vintage: 2000 02/06/2013

Another nose that remains somewhat tight with medicinal cherry, leather, and garrigue aromas framed with a little spice, and a little floral nuance. With a lovely combination of liquory, plump, rich fruit, and a bit a bit of bitterness this fills the mouth that drops off quickly on the backend this is a bit short, but the black berry fruit and plum fruit is just so pretty you can help but seeing this as a fun wine. 89pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
4.50 5
Vintage: 1999 02/06/2013

Tight and focused on the nose with beautiful, spicy, leathery, clean aromas that are still youthful with hints of chalk, spice, and dark fruit On entry this is almost voluptuous with really vibrant acids with decisive cut and round, ample tannins that segue into spicy dark cherry fruit that shows a slightly dried edge. Ultimately this is a little touch but it does exhibit lovely focused, dark fruit and good length, with very chocolatey tannins offering a subtle density here. 93pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065211,108
4.00 5
Vintage: 1998 02/11/2009

Great intensity on the nose with a flush of floral notes followed by plums. dry cow patty, brilliant notes of bloody meat. Soft and richly mouthfilling in the mouth with a layered richness and unusual intensity of flavor centered around dried strawberry, with a subtle shading of dark chocolate and earthy spice. The only fault is the relative simplicity on the palate but this is a true crowd pleaser.


1 2 3 4

User Reviews for Prisoner Orin Swift Napa

Add your review
Snooth User: jtryka
3127992,078
3.50 5
Vintage: 2012 12/17/2013

The nose is a pleasant blend of red fruit, strawberries, plum, green grass and tar. The taste is very jammy up front, with rich fruit, plum, blackberry and strawberry that transitioned to some dusty limestone and smoke midpalate. The finish was smooth and very dry, with a smoky accent that lingered for a good while. See the full review on my blog here: http://allaloneonaplanetfullofpeople.blogspot.com/2013/12/2012-prisoner.html


Snooth User: Mrs Chicago
146698873
3.00 5
Vintage: 2012 02/13/2014

I had an older vintage ... I believe a bit over priced for the lack of depth, but overall a nice balanced wine


Snooth User: pboss
1443772475
3.50 5
Vintage: 2011 03/02/2014

A nice wine from Orin Swift. This is a blend of Zinfandel and a handful of other grapes. Had very nice undertones of earth and stone with some big fruit and a touch of residual sugar. Definitely a bold wine, and though we drank it without food, I suspect this would hold up well almost any type of beef. Again, not great but definitely not bad.


Snooth User: Carlo182
1172944192
4.50 5
Vintage: 2011 01/15/2013

Ripe, wild, lush berries that linger & mix with oak & black tea accents. Bright acidity. Since this is a mix, there is more acidity than a normal zin, so don't be shy to pair with heavier meals. If anything one might err on going with light pairings, and get put off by acid.


Snooth User: shanwich55
462618132
5.00 5
Vintage: 2011 04/23/2010

You are amazing Mr. Prisoner. You are that boyfriend or girlfriend all single people seek to meet. You are deep, complex, and spicy hot. After one date with you, most wine, especially in your price range, just pale in comparison. Blackberry, spice and without fault you are guaranteed to be love at first sight for anyone lucky enough to spend around $30 odd dollars to take you home.


Snooth User: jbblunt54
13809517
4.00 5
Vintage: 2011 10/10/2013

Had it at Meritage. Loved it.


Snooth User: smiles813
1063123319
0.00 5
Vintage: 2010 04/12/2012

$35.99


1 2 3 4 5  ...  19

External Reviews for Prisoner Orin Swift Napa

External Review
Source: Wine Gems @ Perriello's
Vintage: 2013 11/08/2014

Napa Valley, CaliforniaThe new 2013 vintage has arrived and it's very limited, as always. Parker 92!The Prisoner is a must-try red wine gem for anyone who loves Zinfandel! The label was recently sold by gifted winemaker Dave Phinney of Orin Swift Cellars to its new owner, The Prisoner Wine Company. Considering that Wine Spectator has selected The Prisoner to join the ranks of the magazine's Top 100 Wines of the Year not just in one recent year (#47 in 2009 for the 2007 vintage) but 3 times in the past 6 years, it is nearly inconceivable that Dave Phinney began his winemaking career with 2 tons of purchased Zinfandel grapes just a year out of college in 1998! Now he has passed the baton to winemaker Jen Beloz, former winemaker at Ravenswood, to carry on the legacy of The Prisoner. Robert Parker just rated the 2013 vintage 92 points, so don't delay!The Prisoner is 44% Zinfandel blended with 20% Cabernet Sauvignon, 16% Petite Sirah, plus Syrah, Grenache and Charbono. The wine has a deep ruby red hue that is framed in rich crimson. Aromas of black cherry and plum, surrounded by roasted coffee beans and vanillin oak accents. The entry is powerful and lush with ?avors of bing cherry, blueberry and cocoa. Soft and velvety tannins round out the ?nish making this wine approachable and inviting. It was aged in both new and seasoned French and American oak. The wine is soft and round with weight, length and structure and good acidity to soften its big fruit. On the finish it is long and lingering with soft, velvety tannins.Enjoy The Prisoner with roast pork, grilled chicken, BBQ ribs, grilled vegetables and cheeses.


External Review
Source: We Speak Wine
Vintage: 2012 07/10/2014

The wine has a deep ruby red hue that is framed in rich crimson. Aromas of black cherry and plum, surrounded by roasted co ee beans and vanillin oak accents. The entry is powerful and lush with flavors of bing cherry, blueberry and cocoa. Soft and velvety tannins round out the finish making this wine approachable and inviting. - Jen Beloz, WinemakerThe blend:46% Zinfandel22% Cabernet Sauvignon18% Petite Sirah12% Syrah2% CharbonoAging: 30% New Oak, Combination of French and American Oak Barrels ** SOLD OUT **


External Review
Source: Wine Gems @ Perriello's
Vintage: 2012 05/13/2014

Napa Valley, CaliforniaThe new 2012 vintage has arrived, but it's very limited, as always!The Prisoner is a must-try red wine gem for anyone who loves Zinfandel! The label was recently sold by gifted winemaker Dave Phinney of Orin Swift Cellars to its new owner, The Prisoner Wine Company. Considering that Wine Spectator has selected The Prisoner to join the ranks of the magazine's Top 100 Wines of the Year not just in one recent year (#47 in 2009 for the 2007 vintage) but 3 times in the past 6 years, it is nearly inconceivable that Dave Phinney began his winemaking career with 2 tons of purchased Zinfandel grapes just a year out of college in 1998! Now he has passed the baton to winemaker Jen Beloz, former winemaker at Ravenswood, to carry on the legacy of The Prisoner. Robert Parker just rated the 2012 vintage 90 points, so don't delay!The Prisoner is 46% Zinfandel blended with 22% Cabernet Sauvignon, 18% Petite Sirah, 12% Syrah and 2% Charbono. The wine has a deep ruby red hue that is framed in rich crimson. Aromas of black cherry and plum, surrounded by roasted coffee beans and vanillin oak accents. The entry is powerful and lush with ?avors of bing cherry, blueberry and cocoa. Soft and velvety tannins round out the ?nish making this wine approachable and inviting. It was aged in both new and seasoned French and American oak. The wine is soft and round with weight, length and structure and good acidity to soften its big fruit. On the finish it is long and lingering with soft, velvety tannins.Enjoy The Prisoner with roast pork, grilled chicken, BBQ ribs, grilled vegetables and cheeses.


External Review
Source: We Speak Wine
Vintage: 2012 10/29/2013

The wine has a deep ruby red hue that is framed in rich crimson. Aromas of black cherry and plum, surrounded by roasted co ee beans and vanillin oak accents. The entry is powerful and lush with flavors of bing cherry, blueberry and cocoa. Soft and velvety tannins round out the finish making this wine approachable and inviting. - Jen Beloz, WinemakerThe blend:46% Zinfandel22% Cabernet Sauvignon18% Petite Sirah12% Syrah2% CharbonoAging: 30% New Oak, Combination of French and American Oak Barrels


External Review
Source: JJ Buckley Fine Wines
Vintage: 2012 03/21/2014

There are 20 000 cases of the 2012 The Prisoner which is an interesting blend of 46% Zinfandel 22% Cabernet Sauvignon 18% Petite Sirah 12% Syrah and a small amount of Charbono. Its deep ruby/purple color is followed by a big peppery meaty Rhone-like bouquet with hints of bay leaf unsmoked cigar tobacco black currants and sweet jammy cherries. Medium to full-bodied and explosively fruity this is a lovely hedonistic seriously endowed red to drink over the next 3-4 years. - Robert Parker Robert Parkers Wine Advocate.


External Review
Source: Bowery And Vine
Vintage: 2012 10/31/2013

This vintage has a deep ruby hue that is nearly opaque. The aromas elevate from the glass starting with black currant, dark blackberry, cherry, and cassis rounded out by subtle hints of seasoned French and American oak. The entry of the wine is massive and leads into a lush middle framed by bright acid and supple tannins. The finish is long, lingering and filled with soft velvety tannins lasting for nearly thirty seconds.


External Review
Source: Wine Gems @ Perriello's
Vintage: 2012 11/07/2013

Napa Valley, CaliforniaThe new 2012 vintage has arrived, but it's very limited!Orin Swift The Prisoner is a must-try red wine gem from a gifted and fast-rising winemaker, Dave Phinney. Considering that Wine Spectator has selected The Prisoner to join the ranks of the magazine's Top 100 Wines of the Year not just in one recent year (#47 in 2009 for the 2007 vintage) but 3 times in the past 6 years, it is nearly inconceivable that Dave Phinney began his winemaking career with 2 tons of purchased Zinfandel grapes just a year out of college in 1998! He recently purchased 48 acres of land in the hills above Oakville and hopes one day to build a winery there. We can all look forward to enjoying the evolution of Orin Swift Cellars! The 2011 vintage received a 92-point rating from Wine Spectator and we expect a similar score for this one. Robert Parker just rated it 90 points, so don't delay!Orin Swift The Prisoner is 46% Zinfandel blended with 22% Cabernet Sauvignon, 18% Petite Sirah, 12% Syrah and 2% Charbono. The wine is dark red, almost garnet hue with bright red on the rim. Aromas of Bing cherry, espresso, roasted fig and vanillin oak accents are persistent. The entry is powerful and generous supported with lively acidity while flavors of ripe raspberry, pomegranate and wild berry fruit linger harmoniously. It was aged in both new and seasoned French and American oak. The wine is soft and round with weight, length and structure and good acidity to soften its big fruit. On the finish it is long and lingering with soft, velvety tannins.Enjoy Orin Swift The Prisoner with roast pork, grilled chicken, BBQ ribs, grilled vegetables and cheeses.


1 2 3 4 5  ...  108

Ratings & Tags for Prisoner Orin Swift Napa

1445204 Snooth User: Tantle7
rated this wine
5.00 5
2012 01/11/2014

1468164 Snooth User: cmmidlo
rated this wine
4.50 5
2012 02/15/2014

153407 Snooth User: puhnner
rated this wine
3.00 5
2011 11/09/2013

1383861 Snooth User: minocencio
rated this wine
4.00 5
2011 10/28/2013

1129061 Snooth User: Lexa978
rated this wine
5.00 5
2011 12/28/2012

1265519 Snooth User: cc527
rated this wine
4.00 5
2011 03/21/2013

rated this wine
4.50 5
2011 07/24/2014

1 2 3 4 5  ...  34

Winemaker's Notes:

5259896

Tasting Notes:

This vintage has a deep ruby hue that is nearly opaque. The aromas elevate from the glass starting with black currant, dark blackberry, cherry, and cassis rounded out by subtle hints of seasoned French and American oak. The entry of the wine is massive and leads into a lush middle framed by bright acid and supple tannins. The finish is long, lingering and filled with soft velvety tannins lasting for nearly thirty seconds.

5259896

Photos for All Vintages

+ Add Image

1 2 3 4 5  ...  244

Dietary Information: Organic

Notes: The different grape varieties, which have been vinified separately, are blended together after malo-lactic fermentation and matured for six to eight months in large oak barrels. The wine is bottled after fining with egg whites.


Recipe Downloader

RiceSelect

Best Wine Deals

  • $21.99
    33%off
    Ravenswood Zinfandel Sonoma Valley Old Hill
    Ravenswood Zinfandel Sonoma Valley Old Hill 2008
  • $31.99
    22%off
    Iron Horse Vineyards White Blend Alexander Valley Cuvée R T Bar T Vineyard
    Iron Horse Vineyards White Blend Alexander Valley Cuvée R T Bar T Vineyard 2003
See More Deals »







Snooth Media Network