- There are currently no submitted critic scores.
Submit a Critic ScoreClose
Food Pairings for Orin Swift Saldo Premier
11/27/2012 - TSBWINE WROTE: 90 Points 89-91 points. You really have to take this wine for what it is. It's not a dramatic wine or one that even exhibits exceptional structure/balance. In fact, it's somewhat angular with the acid/tannin profile being rather unrefined. However, it's still a tasty wine with some real high points and desirable characteristics that are sometimes hard to find in other wines. The fruit is more typical of a wildberry due its brambly character (spice and pepper) and it's expressive on the nose and palate. There's a nice intensity there yet it's not overripe. This transitions to a very generous mocha/coffee note on the midpalate that's accentuated by the supple tannins and acids. Texturally, there's a convergence of acids and oak tannin that contribute to the overall impression of the characteristic. There's even a milk chocolate note possibly due to lactic acid levels (from MLF) in the wine. No doubt there's an oak influence here too in terms of taste which helps promote the mocha notes. What's most striking is how harmonious the wine becomes on the mid-palate when all these influences intersect. For all its flaws, I admire how it expresses those coffee/mocha notes even if it only does so for a few passing moments. In that sense, it's a classic "palate-building" wine that is so key to building recognition. If you come in with expectations of a traditional wine (Or Zin) you might come away disappointed. However if you approach it with an open mind chances are it will be a far more memorable wine despite its shortcomings. Recommend sharing this with someone who's relatively new to tasting so that you can help them discover some new wine characteristics. I don't know how it will develop over the years but my instinct is that it's best now since it likely wasn't built to age. 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No / Comments (1) Options 11/22/2012 - SHARMLESS11 WROTE: 89 Points Delicious for Thanksgiving Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment Options 11/18/2012 - BVWINO WROTE: 86 Points Hot and disjointed. Think it needs a little more time in the bottle to mellow out. Jo liked it more than me. Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment Options 10/23/2012 - ZANZABAR WROTE: 91 Points First night this was too big. But an hour of decanting on the second night and it mellowed out. Huge nose of dark fruit and cherries, obviously full bodied with a lasting finish which gives it some complexity. Not up to par with the 07 in my opinion, but still a typical Orin Swift. The first night this would have received mid 80s, but it evolved by night 2. Needs lots of air time and certainly more time in the bottle. 1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No / Comment Options 10/19/2012 - JFUREY21 WROTE: 90 Points Wifey loved this wine. I enjoyed it as well, but a little too "overcooked" to rate it higher. this was a big wine - tannins need to resolve a little. Maybe a year away?
Best Wine Deals
Viento Sur Reserva Tannat (2009)Wishlisted
Rombauer Carneros Chardonnay (2012)Wishlisted
Red wine causing leg cramps??Replied
Any experience with these 100 point wines?Posted
Syrah Offline 7/19/14 Sonoma CountyReplied
Im looking for an inexpensive sweet wine(red)Replied
Cave de Lugny Macon-Lugny les Charmes (2010)Reviewed
Chateau Malartic-lagraviere Graves Blancs Pessac-léognan (2006)Wishlisted
Château Pontet-Canet Red Bordeaux Blend Pauillac (1934)Wishlisted
Bodegas Y Vinedos O. Fournier Urban Uco Malbec (2012)Reviewed