Welcome to the snooth forums. Ask questions, assist others, and meet other Snooth users.

Wine Talk

Snooth User: Drunk as a Skunk
Merlot
Posted by Drunk as a Skunk, Oct 1.

Wanting to try my first Merlot. Any suggestion would be appreciated. Looking to start for $20 or under to start with. Thanks

1738
Reply by Gregory Dal Piaz, Oct 1.

I don't know where you are located by I was surprised by this one:

http://www.snooth.com/wine/jacuzzi-merlot-rosso-di-sette-fratelli-nv/

11
Reply by wlstiles3, Oct 1.

I can suggest Red Diamond 07 and Duck Pond Cellars 04, both from Washington. Frankly, I have been hard pressed to find a bad Merlot from Washington. Some grapes were made for some places and Merlot and Washington go well together. Additionally, I find it is easier to find quality in Merlot under $20.

Enjoy and don't let the wine gurus tell you Merlot can't be high quality.

0
30
Reply by TL NJ, Oct 2.

Skunk...

Coincidentally, I just posted a reply to wlstiles note about merlot.

In my note I talked about Washington merlots. I have grown to prefer them over most of the merlots coming out of California, as its a variety that they take rather seriously.

In addition to what others may suggest to you, I would suggest you give some of these a try from Washington. The quality you get for the price you pay is quite surprising. At the $20 or less, I found the following to be excellent...

1. Columbia Crest
2. Covey Run
3. Chateau Ste. Michelle

Enjoy

0
390
Reply by GregT, Oct 3.

"Enjoy and don't let the wine gurus tell you Merlot can't be high quality."

Why would they say that if they're "wine gurus"? Also, there's no reason to think that California can't make good merlot. It is after all, a huge place. Too many to list but the Pahlmeyer merlot from 1994 or 1997 is simply spectacular and as good as any wine produced anywhere IMHO. Pride makes a good one every year. If you want to spend less, Whitehall Lane Reserve Merlot is usually very nice and only around $25 or so and in the same range is the merlot from Steltzner, which can be quite good and which ages nicely too.

There's a big difference between good and bad however, partly because merlot is just harder to make than cab sauvignon. So there's a lot of bad merlot around, just like there's a lot of bad pinot noir.

Columbia Crest, Chat St Michelle, Red Diamond, Snoqualmie, NorthStar, Stimson Estate Cellars, Domaine St Michelle, Conn Creek, and Villa Mt Eden are all owned by the same company which used to be called Stimson Lane but is now called Chateau St Michelle wines. And the first two especially have several different lines. THe basic Columbia Crest is never all that great although a lot of people seem to like it, but their Reserve bottling, which is only around $20, delivers a lot for the price. Also in Washington Januik is around that same price point.

Good luck and happy hunting!

25
Reply by Drunk as a Skunk, Oct 3.

Thanks for the advice everyone. Thanks Greg T for mentioning a lot of pinot noir out there. I tried one a couple weeks ago and couldn't understand all the rave. I actually didn't like it. Maybe I'll give it another try.

11
Reply by wlstiles3, Oct 5.

GregT,

I was just making the point that Merlot has gotten a bad rap IMO. That people tend to shy away from Merlot for whatever reason and that there are some very good wines in this varietal.

By way of generalization, I find that Washington is a place where Merlot does well. That does not preclude quality from other locales.

1738
Reply by Gregory Dal Piaz, Oct 6.

I agree that merlot has gotten a bad rap. Washington does produce some of the better examples coming from the US. It will be interesting to put together a tasting with some examples, maybe I'll move that up in the rotation and get it done for the end of the month.

0
12
Reply by Wayno, Oct 6.

Speaking of great merlots, what about that Patrimo, put out by Feudi di San Gregorio. Absolutely marvelous. There are some other really good Italian merlots out there also.

35
Reply by lingprof, Oct 6.

I feel a little disloyal to CA jumping on the washington wagon ;-). But I had H3 Horse Heaven Hills Merlot, 2006 I think, by Columbia Crest and it was amazing. At $13 or so, I scooped up a bunch to have on hand.

35
Reply by lingprof, Oct 6.

Oh, one I loved from CA is Cameron Hughes Napa Valley Merlot, Lot 79, at about $12. That may be hard to find, but Cameron Hughes, if you can find them at Costco or whatever, has done some nice Merlots in the past.



You must be logged in to reply to topics. Or create an account now to join the discussion!