Wine Talk

Snooth User: ChipDWood

"Glass Acts" (Washington Post)...

Posted by ChipDWood, Aug 24, 2009.

An interesting read regarding the oft-underestimated Virginia vino and some good stuff from Cali- against the French. Of course:

Glass Acts
In Our Wine Tasting, Virginia Shows It Can Compete With France and Napa Valley
By Dave McIntyre
Special to The Washington Post Wednesday, August 19, 2009

The "Judgment of Paris" transformed the world of wine, marking California on the map in big, bold letters that could not be ignored. That May 1976 tasting galvanized an upstart American wine industry that had struggled in the decades since Prohibition and helped overcome a consumer perception here and abroad that American wines were inferior to their French counterparts. The Paris tasting was immortalized in the 2005 book "Judgment of Paris" by George M. Taber and the 2008 movie "Bottle Shock." It has provided a model for countless wine tastings and parties in the decades since, setting the standard that wines should be evaluated based solely on what's in the glass, not on the label.

Where California was in the 1970s -- underappreciated for its quality -- Virginia is today. So when we decided to hold our own Judgment of Washington, it wasn't just to see whether the United States would best France today. It was to see whether local wines might surprise the judges now as much as Napa Valley bottles did more than three decades ago.
We invited six area wine professionals -- three retailers, three sommeliers -- to blind-taste a dozen chardonnays and a dozen red Bordeaux-style wines, telling them only that we were pitting the United States vs. France in a sort of oenological grudge match. Then we slipped in five Virginia wines and one from Maryland without telling anyone.

Could the locals hold their own against the more established competition from Napa Valley, Bordeaux and Burgundy? Could they overcome a market perception that they are expensive novelties that don't offer value to match their price? Or would they fall flat as overreaching pretenders?

When the scores were totaled and the wines unveiled, a California wine narrowly edged out a French rival for the top spot in each category. But Virginia was nipping at their heels.
"Wow, you're really swinging for the fences right away with this one," John Wabeck said as he sniffed the first red wine. Wabeck, a former chef who is now sommelier at Inox restaurant in Tysons Corner and a third-level master sommelier candidate, scribbled "classic Bordeaux structure . . . merlot-based? . . . cocoa powder" and scored it 90 points out of 100. Elli Benchimol, beverage director for the Stir Food Group, which includes Zola and Potenza restaurants and their affiliated wine stores, also noted cocoa powder and scored the wine 90, lauding its "beautiful structure." Brian Cook, sommelier at Sonoma and Blue Ridge in the District and Redwood in Bethesda, praised its "cured meat, savory cassis, mint, mocha" flavors and its "dusty tannins," awarding the wine 92 points.

The wine was Barboursville Vineyards' 2006 Octagon, a merlot-based blend of Bordeaux grape varieties that retails for about $40. Four of the six judges mistook it for a Bordeaux. Ultimately, the Octagon trailed the Newton Vineyards 2005 Unfiltered Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley, a $60 monster that wowed the judges with its unmistakably jammy fruit, velvety texture and spicy complexity. Second place went to Chateau Larrivet-Haut Brion 2005, from the Pessac-Leognan region of Bordeaux, every bit as French as the Newton was American. Like the Octagon, it retails for about $40.

Napa Valley scored points for value, with cabernet sauvignon from Sterling Vineyards ($25) and Beaulieu Vineyard's Rutherford bottling ($20) impressing the judges. But Virginia came in big again, in a fifth-place tie between the Michael Shaps 2007 Cabernet Franc ($35) and the Gordon Brothers 2003 Tradition from Washington state ($45).

California also scored for value with the white wines. Our top finisher -- by a hair -- was the Chappellet 2007 Napa Valley Chardonnay, a $32 charmer that fooled the judges into thinking it was French. Only Vanessa Moore, owner of Unwined retail store in Alexandria, identified it as a Napa wine. (Wine Spectator magazine loved it, too, rating it 91 points, about what our judges gave it.) The Chappellet was in a virtual dead heat with the $50 Louis Latour Chateau de Blagny 2006 Meursault-Blagny Premier Cru. Our judges were unanimous that this was French. Two of them, Dominque Landragin, co-owner of the Cork & Fork stores in Gainesville and Bethesda, and Christian Bonny, wine buyer at Circle Wine & Liquor in Northwest Washington, even guessed the correct appellation. Bonny was so excited about this wine that he got tangled in similes, saying that "it keeps coming around, like a snowball rolling downhill," and after the next sip, "like a ferris wheel of stone fruit and cream."

Right behind the first two, though, came two Virginia chardonnays: Linden Vineyards 2006 Hardscrabble, which retails for about $26, and the Michael Shaps 2007 ($35). Fewer than 1.25 points separated the first four chardonnays, two of them from Virginia. The judges were unanimous in thinking the Shaps was from Burgundy. "Montrachet!" Landragin wrote, while Benchimol, Moore and Wabeck suspected Puligny-Montrachet. The Linden was mistaken for French by three of the judges, while the others suspected the West Coast.

What conclusions can we draw from our exercise? That U.S. wines are the equal of the French is no longer the surprise it was in 1976. Yet it is worth noting that when our judges were asked where they thought a wine was from, they tended to believe the wines they liked most were French. France still holds pride of place in our minds as the benchmark for fine wine.
But we cannot ignore that wines produced within a two-hour drive of Washington stood toe-to-toe with highly touted competitors from California and France. This result is a snapshot of what six judges thought about two dozen wines one July afternoon, yet it should send a signal to retailers, sommeliers and consumers that local wines can match the best in the world -- and they are beginning to do so. It's time to put our preconceptions aside and focus on the quality of these wines.

Dave McIntyre can be reached through his Web site,, or at

Quick note: I'm fortunate enough to have tasted both the Chappellet '07 as well as the Shaps '06... still got a bottle of the Shaps in the cooler over there, with the former waiting for me at verk to buy & try again. Also of note & irony; I too thought immediately about white burgundy, but more along the lines of "Meursault" when I tried the Shaps back at the Wineworks a year ago. I'm sure I was just bieased from hearing where Shaps was trained. Be a great little blind tasting ;).


Reply by Gregory Dal Piaz, Aug 24, 2009.

Very interesting and thanks for posting this.

I would love to put together a tasting like this here at Snooth.

The Judgment of Madison Avenue perhaps?

Reply by Jimmy Cocktail, Aug 24, 2009.

Interesting. I'm supposed to begin working with the Cork and Fork folks starting in a couple of weeks (on the beer side of the house), I'll have to see if there were any surprises that didn't make it into the article.

Reply by ChipDWood, Aug 24, 2009.

I'll tell ya right now that there are more than just a few surprises ;). Shaps is one of the true visionaries in the Commonwealth, and his Chardonnay is spot on. I was lucky enough to get a barrell tasting of the '07 Shaps Meritage (red blend)- and it may be the first Virginny wine to really register on the Parker scale.

It's a different wine making world down there in Virginia. FAR different from out west with a myriad of different obstacles to overcome... but they're on the verge. Watch for the release of several of the mainstay, headliner '07 red blends. Was a great year for the red varietals (Petit Verdot in particular, according to both Shaps & John Higgs from Barren Ridge).

I'm just stoked. Greg, I really think you're going to enjoy some of the Cab Francs & aforementioned blends, as would a healthy number of our fellow Snoothers.

And it's just good to see VA get some cred. It's especially thrilling because when I tasted them myself I truly felt they could be competitive. Now I guess I don't feel so nuts.

Wonderfully rounded & golden hued with just a hint of vindication ;)

Reply by atonalprime, Jan 14, 2010.

Did the Judgement of Madison Avenue ever happens? My curiosity is piqued and I'm trying to prep for a wedding over Memorial Day weekend in the Spring.

Back to Categories

Top Contributors This Month

2200527 Snooth User: sinha
29 posts
127503 Snooth User: rckr1951
20 posts
1464471 Snooth User: William Djubin
1464471William Djubin
12 posts


View All

Snooth Media Network