In the past, Philip has reported on the counterfeit wine problem. Recently I read this article at Slate which in turn led me to read this much older article at the Wine Spectator .
It seems somewhat less pure of a forgery case than the story of Han Van Meegeren . The notorious art forger took a great deal of pride in his work and by all counts was a fantastic artist and painter. He managed to convince some of the most well-known art critics of his day of the authenticity of his forgeries. I say the fake wines are less pure mostly out of ignorance. Without a case study -- a person who has engaged in the act of producing counterfeit wine -- we really cannot know what the motive is. Do these producers take pride in the wines they put into expensive shells? Or is it merely a money making scheme?
On the subject of hoaxes, I find the Museum of Hoaxes to be an excellent read. I'm often amazed by what some people are able to pull off!
I wouldn't be surprised if I discovered that 5% of what I'd come across on a daily basis turned out to be some manner of hoax. How's that for a measured portion of cynicism!
Search the Snooth ForumSearch
- Hello Snooth!7 posts
- Sommelier Position Available PBC, FLA5 posts
- Maui Winery5 posts
- I'll Probably Get Kicked Off the Forum for This Heresy . . .4 posts
- Hello Snooth!2 posts
Top Contributors This Month
- 65 posts
- 58 posts
- 38 posts
Wedding Wines, Part 1Commented
Heitz Cabernet Sauvignon (2009)Cellared
Stag's Leap Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Artemis (2011)Cellared
Clos du Val Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley (2005)Wishlisted
Monte da Ravasqueira Vinha Das Romãs (2011)Reviewed
Laterre White Zinfandel California Other California Wines Rose (2007)Wishlisted
Laterre White Zinfandel Ml RoseWishlisted
Château Franc Jaugue Blanc Red Bordeaux Blend St. Émilion Grand Cru (2009)Cellared
Château Larose-Trintaudon Red Bordeaux Blend Haut-Médoc (2010)Cellared
Chateau Tour de Bessan Margaux (2010)Cellared