+ Add Critic Score

Submit a Critic Score

Score:

Name of Critic:

Close

Barolo Bartolo Mascarello 2004

Winemaker's Notes:

"...This is the best young Barolo I have tasted here in many a year. Fans of traditional Barolo won’t want to miss this superb effort. The 2004 Barolo was fermented for 20-30 days in cement. The malos progressed at an unusually slow pace and weren’t finished until the following summer. The wine was aged in medium-sized casks. Readers can also look forward to promising wines in 2005, 2006 and 2007. I also had a chance to re-taste the 2003, which is a lovely Barolo for nearer-term consumption...95." WA 12/07

Editorial Reviews for Barolo Bartolo Mascarello

Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.50 5
Vintage: 2010 07/11/2014

54 days on the skin Pale and delicate in color, surprisingly so. This is superbly focused on the nose with high toned floral peony and iris notes, gorgeous fruit, precise red currant and small lingonberry aromas framed with something delicately sweet, and bay leaf like. Superbly focused in the mouth, this has fabulous purity and is precise and elegant with this delicate layering of flavors. Fresh red fruit, peach skin, so bright and pure with penetrating aromas on the long finish. The tannins here are so precise, fresh, and ripe, there's great power here but you can taste right through this to the base of soil tones Deceptively small in the mouth, this is packed with such flavor that it is a bit of a shock. Long on the finish with some hint of red plums, this is fabulous. 95pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.50 5
Vintage: 2009 06/26/2013

Intense raspberry fruit, ripe with woodsy edges and mineral, tea, and tobacco highlights topped with a touch of red rose petals all greet the nose. Wide open, and a bit soft on entry then full of intriguing rosehip and raspberry fruit with a little apple skins note and hints of sandalwood on the palate. The tannins here are pretty ripe, but certainly prominent right through the slightly austere finish which shows some alcohol that is just barely perceptible. This has height and perfume in the mouth that is unusual for the vintage, with a fresh and traditional feel. 93pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.50 5
Vintage: 2008 09/27/2012

An abundance of liquory red fruit powers the sweet aromatics, which emerge over a base of dusty white earth with hints of dried rose petal, juniper, mint, salami and old barrel. Gorgeous balance and scale in the mouth is supported by super fine tannins and bright acids that lend lovely purity. The red-fruited, lingonberry-rich mid-palate sees a huge follow through to a wonderful rose hip finish. The only rub might be its small scale, but this is so layered and long that it is truly the essence of Barolo. 94pts


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.50 5
Vintage: 2007 07/02/2011

2007 Bartolo Mascarello Barolo-La Morra - earthy, herbal, a little pork fat, lightly aromatic, some floral notes, nice raspberry fruit, nice fruit up front then lean and fresh with soft tannin and integrated acids, dry savory core to the mid-palate, nice fruit on the backend with a nice strawberry seed finish, fresh and elegant. 9


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.50 5
Vintage: 2007 05/23/2011

Nebbiolo Prima 2011 - Bartolo Mascarello Barolo-La Morra - earthy, herbal, a little pork fat, lightly aromatic, some floral notes, nice raspberry fruit, nice fruit up front then lean and fresh with soft tannin and integrated acids, dry savory core to the mid-palate, nice fruit on the backend with a nice strawberry seed finish, fresh and elegant, 9


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.50 5
Vintage: 2006 10/30/2010

Very floral, nuanced roasted chestnut tones, a bit of chamomile and leather, nice fruit, a touch waxy, very cranberry, wild raspberry fresh. A bit soft up front, very ripe tannins up front then finds its focus on the mid-palate with earthy, slight seedy, dried floral tones, some tea notes, lightly liquory raspberry fruit on the backend. Nice finish, lots of savory, leathery notes on finish, a powerful wine. (90-92pts)


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
2.00 5
Vintage: 2005 05/22/2009

AWE blind tasting - campfire, then sweet herbs, a touch of bacon, some cola, weeds, very fluid in the mouth, softish tannins, some sweetness but not much else, not cloying but very little flavor at this stage. 82-83


1 2 3 4 5

Member Reviews for Barolo Bartolo Mascarello

Add your review
Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.80 5
Vintage: 2010 07/11/2014

Four and a half glasses


Snooth User: Gregory Dal Piaz
89065222,083
4.70 5
Vintage: 2009 06/26/2013

Four and a half glasses


Snooth User: Halthen
35318640
5.00 5
Vintage: 2003 01/13/2010

Five glasses


Snooth User: 97mjr
339902,159
0.00 5
Vintage: 2001 03/04/2009

Tight structured wine. Black fruit, heavy tannins. Would like to try it again but will not buy more


Snooth User: Barberolo
721003,140
4.00 5
Vintage: 2001 01/02/2013

Four glasses


Snooth User: edub
151871330
4.00 5
Vintage: 2000 08/08/2009

we knew we were drinking this young, so we gave it about 6 hours of decanting, with some sips along the way. Nose of bright berry fruit, nice acidity, tea, spices, plum compote, more strawberries, and red licorice. It became more integrated by the time we were ready to drink it, but it was still very tight, and only starting to show its dimension and class. Needs a lot more time, special juice here.


Snooth User: 97mjr
339902,159
0.00 5
Vintage: 1998 03/04/2009

According to a sommelier at Cru, in a vertical tasting, drinking better than the '97; the '95 is weak


1 2

External Reviews for Barolo Bartolo Mascarello

External Review
Source: Vintners Cru
03/15/2012

2004 is the first normal vintage I can remember in a while," says Maria Theresa Mascarello. "We were finished with our Nebbiolo harvest on the 12th of October." Her pure, finessed 2004 Barolo offers a compelling array of perfumed violets, dark cherries and baking spices with superb clarity and delineation. A weightless, ethereal Barolo, it reveals notable freshness and supple tannins on the long, finessed finish. Although I have tasted this wine many times from cask, I first encountered it from bottle at a blind tasting where it was immediately recognizable for its style, purity and class. This is the best young Barolo I have tasted here in many a year. Fans of traditional Barolo won't want to miss this superb effort. The 2004 Barolo was fermented for 20-30 days in cement. The malos progressed at an unusually slow pace and weren't finished until the following summer. The wine was aged in medium-sized casks. Readers can also look forward to promising wines in 2005, 2006 and 2007. I also had a chance to re-taste the 2003, which is a lovely Barolo for nearer-term consumption." RP


External Review
Vintage: 2001 07/11/2007

Bartolo Mascarello's wines shine in even the most paltry of years. Here add to the fact that this vintage is brilliant and you'll be moved to tears if you can hang on to this baby for another decade or more.


External Review
Vintage: 2000 11/28/2009

A wonderfully balanced Barolo that is redolent of earth, truffles, berries and spice. Aged in large old barrels and made in such a traditional style that you should either save this for decades or drink with a good decanting and earth-driven fare.


External Review
Vintage: 2000 01/16/2009

Gorgeous, exotic nose, with plums, prunes, cedar and mushrooms. Full-bodied and hedonistic, with loads of ripe fruit and spices underneath. Long and velvety. This is magnificent. The maestro of classic Barolos pulls out all the stops. Best after 2008... Wine Spectator. A Nebbiolo wine from Piedmont in Italy. 2000 Bartolo Mascarello Barolo 750ml


External Review
Vintage: 1999 07/11/2007

1999 produced classic wines for ageing that were deceptively restrained apon release. While still a baby this bottling has begun to reveal some of the profound aromatics Bartolo has been able to echieve while in the mouth the wine remains a lighter, femine expression of nebbiolo.


External Review
Vintage: 1998 09/15/2010

Unusually accessible for such a young wine from this staunch traditionalist. Redolent of tea leaves, plum and star anise.


External Review
Vintage: 1997 07/11/2007

Bartolo's persistence with the traditional technique of blending wine from different vineyards works exceptionally well in vintages of extremes such as 1997. One of the wines of the vintage this offering is certainly marked by the opulence of the year but retains a vibrancy rarely found in 1997.


1 2


"...This is the best young Barolo I have tasted here in many a year. Fans of traditional Barolo won’t want to miss this superb effort. The 2004 Barolo was fermented for 20-30 days in cement. The malos progressed at an unusually slow pace and weren’t finished until the following summer. The wine was aged in medium-sized casks. Readers can also look forward to promising wines in 2005, 2006 and 2007. I also had a chance to re-taste the 2003, which is a lovely Barolo for nearer-term consumption...95." WA 12/07

Best Wine Deals

See More Deals






Snooth Media Network