Wines Then and Now : Part 2

Selecting priceworthy wines from Tuscany and the Rhone Valley


This is the second part in a three part series on wine prices over the past decade. Part one can be found here, and today I follow up with part two, a look at Tuscan wines and the wines of the Rhone Valley.
I love Tuscan wines and I love Sangiovese. Pure, fresh, fruity and austere all at once, it’s one of the greatest food wines on the planet, and in the right hands it occasionally produces some profound wines. I’ve been buying less Tuscan wines as of late, at least at the higher price points, simply because the prices have, in my opinion, outrun the quality in most cases. Now don’t get me wrong, the wines we’re going to take a look at here are top notch, but are they really that much better than similar wines that cost, at least for the moment, half the price or less? I don’t think so.
I’ve put asterisks next to the producers that I think are still worth buying from a value, as well as qualitative standpoint. There is no arguing that Le Pergole Torte is a thing of beauty, but it’s just a little too expensive if you ask me. On the other hand, the I Sodi di San Niccolo continues to be quite a bargain and the Fontalloro, which hasn’t seen a price increase in a decade? Well that is simply a steal. 
I don’t expect many of these Tuscan producers to see much more of a price increase down the pipe. While they are delicious, there are too many great Tuscan wines that offer just about the same experience for $50 or less. Unlike Barolo, Tuscany is a very large region with massive potential supply, and plenty of conscientious winemakers ready to undermine strength in the marketplace for their own advantage. And besides, as good as Tuscan wines are, they aren’t as good as Barolo!

1 2 next

Mentioned in this article


  • Snooth User: steve666
    392767 156

    The explosion of wine prices during the last five years is reflective of the fact that around the world, during an international depression, the rich are getting richer and the middle and working class are getting poorer. Many inexpensive wines have fallen in price, particularly those from Australia, South America, and Spain. Taxes on the excessive earnings of the upper classes would do a lot to restrain the ridiculous prices of the upper tier wines. I think this is especially true for Napa wines sold in CA.

    Jan 23, 2013 at 5:33 PM

  • I am a fan of both Beaucastel and Vieux Telegraph. I am buying myself a birthday present. Which one of the two and which year, 99 0r 2010, I should get.

    Jan 24, 2013 at 10:23 AM

  • Snooth User: mtedo
    1005730 1

    To steve666--please peddle your leftist ideology elsewhere.

    Jan 24, 2013 at 10:35 PM

  • Snooth User: yayfemales
    1163588 21

    leftist ideology is fine with me - the left-leaning drink wine too - but i agree that this is not the place for politics (nor religion). this is the place for wine, all un-fraught.

    Jan 25, 2013 at 5:12 PM

Add a Comment

Search Articles

Best Wine Deals

See More Deals

Snooth Media Network