$20 Pinot Noir

Finding varietal Pinot Noir with that little thing called terroir.

 


Last week I wrote up some reviews on “value priced” Pinot Noir, and I received a few comments asking if it was worth spending a few more dollars on wines costing a bit more. It was a fair question, and one I myself had explored just a week or two early when I compared “value priced” Sauvignon Blancs with wines costing just a few dollars more. The answer to the question is that of course you can get a better wine at a higher price point but, that is by no means a foregone conclusion.
 
There were some standout wines in this group, the 2010 Santa Barbara Winery Pinot Noir is not my style of wine but it delivers a ton of flavor and fruit for $20, so not only can I say that it’s notably better than the “value priced” wines samples last week, but it’ll also give some wines twice the price a run for their money, particularly with consumers looking for this rather intense style. Following on the heels of the Santa Barbara Winery Pinot Noir is a tightly packed group of four wines, all offering distinctive expressions of Pinot Noir where terroir begins to play a role. A bit surprisingly my favorite of the bunch was also from Santa Barbara, the 2011 Byron which was really a very satisfying glass of Pinot, lean, focused and with admirable varietal character!
Of course there are also wines that didn’t appeal to me, as can be the case with a fickle grape such as Pinot Noir. Let’s face it, rating and reviewing wine is an inexact science at best, and people have vastly differing palates, but I do believe that most people, given a set of wines, can make a fair assessment as to the relative quality and/or enjoyability of those wines vis a vis each other. On thing that consumers often value more than reviewers is more. More oak, more weight, more tannin, more fruit. In fact I think that this has been the commercial strategy of the wine industry, and certainly the California's Pinot Noir Industry for much of the past two decades.
 
We are moving beyond the more is better paradigm, focusing on things like nuance and complexity as opposed to more intensity, though that remains a valid and sought after expression of Pinot Noir. My point here is that with Pinot Noir in particular, a grape that is equally capable of both nuanced and powerfully styled wines, it’s tough at times to arbitrarily decide that a wines is not that good because it’s produced in a  style you don’t particularly like. I try as best I can to identify why I don’t like a particular wine, which is why both the wine review and the numerical score associated with it have value. 
 
The bottom line, there is a lot to like at $20 when it comes to Pinot Noir. There are wines that begin to show real refinement, complexity and nuance but if you are looking for subtlety and drinkability, you may very well be just as happy sticking to the top offering in the “value priced” end of the market. I find appealing wines ay both prive points, but the best here really do start to be interesting to me as opposed to merely enjoyable. 

1 2 3 next

Top $20 Pinot Noir Tasted /2013

1.
Santa Barbara Winery Pinot Noir (2010)
List It
2.
Byron Pinot Noir San Barbara1 (2011)
List It
3.
Hofstatter "Mezcan" Pinot Nero Alto Adige Italy Pinot Noir (2010)
List It
4.
Wairau River Wines Pinot Noir (2011)
List It
5.
Gloria Ferrer Pinot Noir Carneros (2010)
List It

Mentioned in this article

Comments

  • I would like to unsubskribe from this
    Best regards
    Anne Thormann
    T
    thormann@live.dk

    Sep 12, 2013 at 10:15 AM


  • Snooth User: olikerj
    1323734 9

    It is disappointing that there is only one Oregon pinot on this list--would have liked to see more Oregon reviews in the $20-25 price range.

    Sep 12, 2013 at 3:32 PM


  • I'd be interested to hear more about good Oregon pinots in a $20-25 price range,i rarely find any for under $40.

    Sep 12, 2013 at 3:43 PM


  • Snooth User: olikerj
    1323734 9

    I would try any of the following: Lemelson, Thea's Selection; Four Graces (2010); Soter, North Valley; Cristom, Mt. Jefferson; anyting from Patricia Green (if you can find it); Carlton Cellars, Seven Devils or Cape Lookout.

    Sep 12, 2013 at 4:00 PM


  • Snooth User: JonDerry
    Hand of Snooth
    680446 3,078

    Re: Oregon, Cameron is another name though not much distribution outside Portland, OR.

    Sep 13, 2013 at 7:21 AM


  • Snooth User: Newport5
    1311224 39


    There are so many great Pinots that weren't discussed, many from Santa Barbara and Paso Robles. I guess I disagree with some of your choices but they are your choices. Love Oregon Pinots as well. Once over $20, you get to some really good bottles.

    Sep 13, 2013 at 5:59 PM


  • Take a look at White Rose, they have some great pinots. They seem to capture Oregon in every bottle.

    Nov 27, 2013 at 8:41 AM


Add a Comment

Search Articles


Recipe Downloader

RiceSelect

Best Wine Deals

See More Deals »

Daily Wine WisdomMore Wine Tips








Snooth Media Network